(HKFGP) Film Review #79: JULY RHAPSODY

Ivan Chin • September 19, 2023

 

Hong Kong Film Gala Presentation

Film Review #79: JULY RHAPSODY

*This film review may contain plot spoilers, reader discretion is advised.*

In July Rhapsody, a mid-life crisis unfurls as a domestic drama of a school teacher’s marriage woes. When his wife’s ex-lover makes an intrusion into their lives, it brings back old memories both had chosen to forget. To further complicate matters, a precocious female student tries to tempt him with her seductions. Ann Hui’s domestic drama contemplates past and present romances, reflects upon one’s inner desires but finds redemption within regret. July Rhapsody comes across as a genuine attempt to work through a troubled marriage, even as the couple look back with nostalgia on their own youth.

 

Hui, known for her films that tackle social issues, treats July Rhapsody as a romance film but approaches its subject from a mature perspective. Much as it would be easy to sensualise it, Hui is restrained in how she deals with the sensitive subject of teacher student relationships. As authoritative figures that students typically look up to, it becomes a conundrum that complicates life both in and out of school. The film puts this at the forefront of the narrative, and while it places a strain on the family, becomes essential when the couple are forced to find closure to past problems.

Bruce lee

Film still from July Rapsody


Ching (Anita Mui) is sought out by her old flame, their teacher, who is ailing. It creates tension between her and Lam, who becomes struck with insecurity. Now older and a mother of two, she feels obliged to settle any unresolved hurts by being his caretaker in his last days. Lam (Jacky Cheung) becomes mired in his own insecurities when he attends a class reunion, seeing his old friends now leading lavish lives while he earns less as a teacher. With the passion of his marriage burnt out, he is swayed when a younger student Woo (Karena Lam) shows interest in him. Lam’s predicament then, feels like a repeat of history, a mistake that he is determined not to commit.

Film still from July Rapsody


July Rhapsody is guided by the moral values that Lam as a school teacher espouses. Even when he is met with temptations, there’s always that inkling of rationale in his eyes. His role as a teacher of literature carries with it a poetic sense of reasoning, and he digs into that in order to curb his own emotions and impart moral values to Woo. While the implication of their relationship is outrageous in its own right, the poetic approach softens it. July Rhapsody has a premise that would normally be deemed taboo in the eyes of Chinese audiences. Hui however, frames these interactions to place Lam in a more redemptive light as he seeks to make things right.



Film still from July Rapsody


It’s also great to see Jacky Cheung act opposite Anita Mui. The two leads share a chemistry, but unlike that of young lovers, they play the old married couple convincingly. Nestled comfortably in each others arms, with an intimacy that comes from years of understanding the other party. It’s a marriage that’s dictated by trust and commitment, only punctuated by the occasional moments of sentimental reminiscing. As each strives to find closure to past problems, it forces them to be honest with one another, and through that bridge the distance between.


Film still from July Rapsody


One might see the film as one that paints the younger, innocent female student as the temptress who seeks to ruin a happy family. Such was the case when Ching had an affair with her teacher, and now when Woo is trying the same with Lam. However, the truth is often more nuanced, and this is exemplified by the fickle way each character behaves. There’s a constant fluctuation of emotions at play, stirring up confusion between the mind and the heart.

 

Ann Hui doesn’t always promise the happiest of endings with her films, but each seeks to provide catharsis by offering a form of closure to the issues at hand. July Rhapsody sees Lam and Ching come to terms with their own mistakes and emotional baggage, allowing them to be free of past burdens that weighed them down.


——————————————————————————-


About the Author:  Ivan Chin has a penchant for Hong Kong cinema and science-fiction films, but enjoys anything from blockbusters to the avant-garde. His favourite directors include Johnnie To, Denis Villeneuve and Stanley Kubrick. He also fervently hopes to see local films blossom. In his free time, he can usually be found wandering around cinemas.


This review was written for Hong Kong Film Gala Presentation happening on 29 September - 1 October 2023.


Tickets are available here: https://shaw.onl/HKFG23 

BLOG

By Luthf Izz Qaisy March 3, 2025
Film Review #167: Mother!
By Zheng Hao March 3, 2025
Different Language, Same Tongue: A Conversation with Lim Yen and her film Exits / Entrances (SYFF) 
By Victoria Khine March 3, 2025
Somewhere Beyond the Rainbow: From Southeast Asia to Hollywood—why black and white is the Golden Age
By Xinyi March 3, 2025
Betwixt and Between: Liminality and recurrence in postcolonial Singapore (SYFF)
By Amadeus Yeo March 3, 2025
Finding the Intersection between Queerness and Religion: Unlearning, Relearning (SYFF)
By Rachel Xia February 22, 2025
Worlds Apart , Yet Never Apart —A Review of Worlds Apart (2024) 影片《异国日记》观后感
By Belle Wong February 15, 2025
Her Story (2024): The new revolution of China's female narrative
By Chew Yiwei February 5, 2025
The Ordinariness of Grief An Analysis of Close (2022)
By Jayden Lim February 3, 2025
Film Review: The Silence of the Lambs
By Raksha Murali January 27, 2025
Joker: Folie à Deux Review This review contains spoilers. Read at your own risk!
More Posts
Share by: